Sometime after discarding Makoto, the Goddess summons two other humans from Earth to become her heroes. One of them is Hibiki Otonashi, who studied in the same school as Makoto's. As a gifted individual from an affluent family, Hibiki was bored with her life as she never had to face any hardhips, having easily overcome any test and trial she faced and is convinced by the goddess to serve her when she offered Hibiki a chance to truly challenge herself. After forming her party, she grew stronger and accumulated victories until they came across Mio in her spider form and were almost killed by her. The other hero was Tomoki Iwahashi, a middle school student who had difficulty with people from being bullied because of his attractive features and could not handle women. The goddess bestowed Tomoki with the ability to become immortal at night and the power to charm any woman with his left eye, which he unintentionally used to charm all members of his party. He attempted to do the same with Tomoe during an encounter with her, but failed. However, the princess Tomoki serves, Lily Front Gritonia, resisted his charm, and pretending to be infatuated by him, started manipulating Tomoki for her own gains.