After a failed attempt to seduce Klaus, Thea wonders if anybody else in Lamplight are interested in romance. Sara then approaches her, seeking advice on how to deal with a boy named Dominic Maura who keeps sending her love letters despite her turning down his advances. Thea suggests that Sara go on a date with Dominic to confirm if she really has feelings for him or not. During the date, all of the Lamplight quietly watch over Sara, but after it appears that Dominic has genuine feelings for Sara, most of them lose interest and leave. Thea, however, checks Dominic's desires and has Lamplight investigate him. In truth, Dominic is actually a con artist by the name of Tarik Pupke who specializes in romance scams, and he was planning to steal Sara's dog to resell to a rich buyer. With all of Lamplight is angered, Thea takes the lead to bring Tarik to justice. With Thea's help, Sara is able to turn the tables and seduce Tarik instead, convincing him to admit his crimes. Afterwards, Klaus offers to take Sara on a date to encourage her desire for romance. Thea confides to Monika that she washed out of her academy because she was too skilled at seduction and had too many improper relationships with the school staff, all in an effort to emulate Hearth. Later that night, Monika asks Klaus why Thea's seduction attempts don't work on him, and he explains that Thea needs to make eye contact with her target for her ability to work, which he has been avoiding all this time. Thea then attempts to seduce Klaus by having Grete dress up as a Playboy Bunny, only to have Klaus bluntly turn her down.