A difficult decision has to be made on the farm "Green Gables". Can Anne stay with her foster parents, the Cuthberts, or does she have to go back to the orphanage? Perhaps she should even go to Mrs. Blewitt, who would love to take Anne into her home, but is unbearably strict? Marilla Cuthbert is very fond of Anne and has always wanted a daughter. But, she wonders, are those enough reasons to keep Anne with you?